American Silver Eagles: Why They’re Still the Most Collected Silver Coin in the U.S.

Since 1986, the American Silver Eagle has been the cornerstone of silver investing and collecting in the United States. It’s not only the most widely recognized 1 oz silver coin globally, it’s also a favorite among investors, collectors, and those selling Silver American Eagle coins for top dollar.

At Big Apple Coins, we specialize in U.S. Mint bullion and are proud to be a go-to silver buyer NYC residents trust. Whether you're picking up a few coins or liquidating part of your stack, our in-store expertise and wide selection make the process smooth, fair, and informative.

Why Collectors Love Silver Eagles

Silver Eagles offer something for everyone, from the casual investor to the advanced numismatist.

• Pure & Backed by the U.S. Government: Each coin contains 1 troy ounce of .999 fine silver, making it ideal for those seeking a stable silver investment.

• Iconic Design: The beloved "Walking Liberty" design by Adolph A. Weinman graces the obverse, while the reverse transitioned in 2021 from the traditional heraldic eagle to a sleek, flying eagle, creating two collectible types for that year.

• Finish Variety: The U.S. Mint has released the Silver Eagle in bullion, proof, burnished, reverse proof, and enhanced proof finishes, giving collectors a wide range to explore.

If you're selling Silver American Eagle coins, Big Apple Coins offers fair market prices and a fast, secure in-person transaction process.

Key Collectible Issues

While all Silver Eagles are desirable, some low-mintage and special-issue coins stand out:

• 1995-W Proof: With a tiny mintage of just over 30,000, this coin commands prices in the tens of thousands in top grade.

• 2006 Reverse Proof: Released for the 20th anniversary, this edition introduced a new finish to the series.

• 2019-S Enhanced Reverse Proof: Limited to 30,000 coins, this modern rarity is prized by collectors nationwide.

As experienced silver eagle coin dealers, we can help you find high-grade examples, or offer top-dollar if you're ready to sell.

Why Buy Silver Eagles from Big Apple Coins?

Whether you’re a collector or an investor, it’s important to work with a reputable silver dealer who can offer real knowledge, fair prices, and a hands-on buying experience. That’s where Big Apple Coins shines.

Here’s why NYC turns to us when looking for a silver buyer or quality bullion:

• In-Store Confidence: Browse our inventory of Silver Eagles, 10 oz silver bars for sale, and silver rounds for sale in person, no surprises or gimmicks.

• Expert Advice: Have questions about mintage, grading, or timing the market? Our staff has decades of experience to help you make smart choices.

• Top-Tier Inventory: Beyond Silver Eagles, we stock all major bullion types, We have junk silver for sale, 1 kilo bars, poured silver, commemorative rounds, and more.

• Sell With Confidence: Looking to liquidate? As a trusted silver buyer NYC collectors depend on, we offer competitive payouts with no pressure.

• Appointments Available: Want one-on-one attention or discreet service? You can schedule an appointment for a private consultation with our team.

Final Thoughts

The American Silver Eagle isn’t just the most collected silver coin, it’s also one of the most liquid, tradable, and recognized silver products on the market. Whether you’re buying your first coin, completing a date set, or selling Silver American Eagle coins from your collection, Big Apple Coins is the reputable silver dealer New Yorkers trust.

Visit our shop today, or schedule an appointment for personalized service. 

Searching for a trusted silver buyer near you? You just found one.